Book Reviews
5:03 am
Wed August 6, 2014

An Heir To E.M. Forster's Vision In 'Every Stone'

Originally published on Tue August 19, 2014 5:38 pm

Every literate nation should have the epics it deserves. The Indian subcontinent already has Salman Rushdie's Midnight's Children (among a few others), and now we can add to that illuminating company Kamila Shamsie's new novel, A God in Every Stone. Stretching from the ancient Persian Empire to the waning days of the British Empire, the novel has an enormous wingspan that catches a wonderful storyteller's wind.

The main action begins on the eve of World War I, with Vivian Rose, an enlightened young British woman who goes to Turkey for an archaeological dig in the company of an old family friend, a Turkish man named Tahsin Bey. Bey is searching for an artifact from the earliest days of the Persian Empire, a silver circlet once belonging to an early Persian king, which Alexander the Great himself supposedly carried to India. Vivian, smitten as only a schoolgirl can be with the dashing archaeologist, falls in love with both man and profession, and even becomes taken with the light itself in this part of the world — "brilliant without being harsh, it made her feel she'd spent her whole life with gauze over her eyes."

That image of regaining sight after growing up blind soon assumes an ironic power. As the war overtakes such civilized practices as archaeology, Vivian returns to England, and never sees Bey again. Years later, she travels east again, this time to the Peshawar Valley as an independent new woman — but in some way she's still on a quest for that mysterious silver circlet. And her vision is still deeply bound to the landscape: "The mountains, oh everywhere, the mountains! Dark green, almost black, mountains; blue mountains; rose-colored mountains; and away in the distance, snow-topped mountains."

On her long train ride through this fabled territory, she encounters Qayyum Gul, a young Muslim man from Peshawar, a soldier of the English Crown, who lost an eye in combat at Ypres. Both Qayyum and his mountainous home become part of Vivian's life — and eventually, so does Qayyum's brother Najeeb.

Najeeb is an archaeologist, the director of a small museum in Peshawar. In the spirit of E.M. Forster and his own attempt at fusing east and west in A Passage to India, Shamsie portrays Najeeb as the successor to the Englishwoman's vision of the region.

"What he most loves in Peshawar," she writes, "is the proximity of the past. All around the broken bowl of the Peshawar Valley his glance knows how to burn away time. So in a single day he might encounter the Chinese monk Fa-Hien throwing flowers into the Buddha's alms bowl at Gor Khatri while recalling the eight elephants who with their united strength could not drag the alms bowl away from the monastery; the Kushan king Kanishka laying the foundation for the Great Stupa which the Buddha had prophesied he would build; the Mughal Emperor Babar, seated on the back of an elephant, hunting rhinos in the swampy marshland where later his descendants would create gardens."

The past has its glories and its beautiful images. Meanwhile, in the novel's present-day Peshawar, tension between the occupying English and the militant Indians, Hindu and Muslim alike, grows more and more menacing. But even as disaster — the possibility that British forces may massacre peacefully demonstrating civilians — seems imminent, our empathy for the Gul brothers and their civilized British friend grows. As does the novel's breadth.

From the far distant past of the Persian Empire to the British massacre in Peshawar, we can see the outline of that ancient circlet boldly portrayed, representing a bond between times and peoples that brings to mind Forster's famous dictum about linking people, places, histories — "Only connect." In this way, Najeeb looks at the circlet and sees "a greeting across centuries."

Why not read this beautifully composed and often terribly moving novel in the same way?

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

Now a new novel that takes us back about a century to what is now Pakistan. It's written by Kamila Shamsie who was born in Pakistan and now lives in London. She's been called one of the best young novelists in Britain by Granta Magazine. And our reviewer Alan Cheuse says, that praise is merited. Here's his take on Shamsie's sixth novel, "A God In Every Stone."

ALAN CHEUSE, BYLINE: In the summer of 1914 Vivian Spencer, a young, enlightened British woman, is participating in an archaeological dig in Turkey in the company of an old family friend - a local man named Tahsin Bey. Bey is searching for an artifact from the earliest days of the Persian Empire - a silver circlet that once belonged to an early Persian king which Alexander the Great himself supposedly carried to India. As the war overtakes such civilized practices as archaeology, Vivian returns to England. But the quest for that silver circlet stays in her mind. When we meet her next she's traveling to the Peshawar Valley as an independent woman hoping to begin a dig of her own. On the train she encounters Qayyum Gul, a young Muslim man from Peshawar - a soldier of the English crown whose lost an eye in combat in the battle of Ypres and finds himself suddenly shifting his loyalties from the West to the East. Vivian next meets Qayyum's brother, Najeeb, who becomes an archaeologist and directs a small museum in Peshawar. What he, Najeeb, most loves in Peshawar, we hear, is the proximity of the past. All around the broken bowl of the Peshawar Valley his glance knows how to burn away time. As does this novelist. In 1930s Peshawar tension between the occupying English and the militant Indians - Hindu and Muslim alike - grows more and more menacing, testing all sorts of loyalties and friendships. From the far distant past of the Persian Empire to the 1930s massacre in Peshawar we can see the outline of that fabled circlet rise to the surface in a bond between times and people's that history will put to the test. Shamsie's memorable rendering of this story brings to mind E. M. Forster's famous dictum about linking history, people and places - only connect, only connect. In this way, Najeeb looks at the circlet and sees a greeting across centuries. Why not read this beautifully composed and often wonderfully moving novel in the same way?

SIEGEL: The novel is "A God In Every Stone" by Kamila Shamsie. Our reviewer is Alan Cheuse. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.